Cassandra Austen, Clergyman’s Daughter: Miss Austen, by Gill Hornby

By Brenda S. Cox

“Cassandra was the executor of her sister’s estate: the keeper of her flame; the protector of her legacy. In the time that was left to her, she was determined to find and destroy any evidence that might compromise Jane’s reputation. It was simply imperative that those letters did not fall into the wrong hands.”–Miss Austen, by Gill Hornby

Miss Austen: A Novel,  by Gill Hornby

Cassandra Austen was Jane Austen’s dearest friend and only sister. Much of what we know about Austen’s life comes from her letters to Cassandra. The oldest sister in the family, who never married, would always have been called “Miss Austen,” while her younger sister was “Miss Jane Austen” or “Miss Jane.”

Gill Hornby retells Cassandra’s life, intertwining fact and fiction. Miss Austen is an imaginative but serious novel. It shows us the life choices available to clergymen’s daughters like Jane and Cassandra.

In old age, Cassandra is frail and not totally clear in her mind. She goes to visit the family of her former fiancé, Tom Fowle. Her goal? To find Jane’s letters and destroy any that might hurt Jane’s reputation.

Cassandra finds and reads some of the (fictional) letters. As she reads, she remembers important events in her life: Her own courtship and engagement. Tom Fowle’s death. Her brothers’ courtships, marriages, and children. The move to Bath. An aborted seaside romance. Jane’s death. Cassandra reflects on the choices she made, and her relationship with her beloved sister.

Miss Austen tells a story of clergymen’s daughters in Austen’s time, through the eyes of Jane’s sister Cassandra.
A Clergyman’s Daughters

In the meantime we see Cassandra’s friends, the Fowle sisters, soon after their father’s death in 1840. Their father, Rev. Fulwar Craven Fowle, was the brother of Rev. Thomas Fowle, Cassandra’s deceased fiancé. Fulwar was a clergyman, and the new clergyman will arrive soon. Therefore Fulwar’s daughter, Isabella Fowle, has to vacate the parsonage she has lived in all her life. Hornby tells us:

“How the village would miss having this family at its center. To lose a much-loved vicar was one blow; to lose his womenfolk quite another. Fulwar was a popular preacher, an active and, on the whole, fair politician, but he had spent much of his week riding to hounds. It was the women who provided the vital care the parishioners needed: the broth for the sick, the clothes for the poor, the basic education.”

Hornby is describing Rev. Fulwar Fowle as a country “squarson,” a combination of squire and parson. Fowle lives a squire’s life, hunting and probably serving as local magistrate. On Sundays he leads services and preaches. The women of the family provide for the poor and the sick. These are roles of both the clergyman’s wife and the squire’s wife (as we see in Emma).

Fowle’s three sisters choose different life roles. One finds fulfillment in caring for the children of factory workers while their mothers work long hours. Another had married and lived in India. She is now a widow with her own home. Isabella has devoted herself to caring for her irascible father. But by the end of the novel, Isabella has a new hope.

Cassandra connects with these women. She looks back at her own life, as the unmarried daughter of a deceased clergyman. In the process, she finds peace with her own life choices. (She died five years later, in 1845.)

Miss Austen by Gill Hornby, hardback cover

In the middle of the novel, during the frustrated romance, I felt this book was too sad for me, and I almost stopped reading. However, I’m glad I pressed on, as there were many treasures still in store.

I recommend this novel as a moving portrayal of Jane Austen’s family and friends, and the possibilities and realities of Cassandra’s life. We also get a deep personal view of the challenges and joys of clergymen’s daughters like Jane and Cassandra.

Favorite Quotes from the Novel

“Happy endings are there for us somewhere, woven into the mix of life’s fabric. We just have to search the detail, follow the pattern, to find the one that should be our own.”

“There was an invisible line between usefulness and intrusion and she well knew the perils of crossing it.”

“Cassandra was dutiful, had possibly been born dutiful, certainly could only be dutiful: She knew of no other way. In her own—for want of a better word—virtue, she had found an endless reward. She was not unique in this. The world, she well knew, was full of good women like her, who dedicated their time, their bodies, their thoughts, and their hearts to the service of others. And if they, and she, were rendered invisible: Well then, what of it? Let us just pity those who had not eyes to see.”

Gill Hornby has also written a children’s biography of Jane Austen, Jane Austen: The Girl with the Golden Pen, which is now available for Kindle.

How do you feel about the life choices you have made? I have been reading* about discernment, trying to see what God’s will may be for us and make right choices. In the end the author says, sometimes we just don’t know the best course, but we choose as well as we can, wanting God’s will, and God honors that. Even when we make choices that are not the best, God can bring good from those as well. Have you seen in your life that God has brought good things even from a choice with painful consequences?


*The book I’ve been reading is God’s Voice Within, by Mark Thibodeaux. An interesting perspective.


I have lost a treasure, such a sister, such a friend as never can have been surpassed. She was the sun of my life, the gilder of every pleasure, the soother of every sorrow; I had not a thought concealed from her, and it is as if I had lost a part of myself. I loved her only too well — not better than she deserved, but I am conscious that my affection for her made me sometimes unjust to and negligent of others; and I can acknowledge, more than as a general principle, the justice of the Hand which has struck this blow.     You know me too well to be at all afraid that I should suffer materially from my feelings; I am perfectly conscious of the extent of my irreparable loss, but I am not at all overpowered and very little indisposed, nothing but what a short time, with rest and change of air, will remove. I thank God that I was enabled to attend her to the last, and amongst my many causes of self-reproach I have not to add any wilful neglect of her comfort.



7 thoughts on “Cassandra Austen, Clergyman’s Daughter: Miss Austen, by Gill Hornby

  1. Hi, I tried to add a comment here but am being asked for information I don’t have.
    I enjoy your blog posts and would recommend this book, although sad, for its research and imaginative insight.
    I’m now confused though because, in reading it, I thought the Fulwar who had died was the brother of Tom, Isabella etc. Given the ages of Cassandra etc at the time it is set, their father (also I think called Fulwar and referred to at times in the story) would have had to have been very old by then.
    Best wishes,
    Marion Shirley

    Get Outlook for Android



  2. Good question, Marion. All these names are confusing. Here’s what the book says:

    “The Reverend Thomas Fowle, Vicar of Kintbury, and his wife, Mrs. Jane Fowle, had four sons:

    Fulwar Craven succeeded his father as Vicar of Kintbury, and married Eliza Lloyd. They had three sons and three daughters, Mary-Jane, Elizabeth, and Isabella.

    Tom was betrothed to Cassandra.

    William became a military physician, and Charles a lawyer. Both died young.”

    So, Tom (Cassandra’s fiance) was Fulwar’s brother. But Mary-Jane, Elizabeth, and Isabella were Fulwar’s daughters. This is the Fulwar who has died shortly before the story begins.

    This is confirmed by Deirdre Le Faye’s Family Record.
    Fulwar died in 1840. Cassandra died in 1845.

    So, to answer your question, Fulwar was Tom’s brother. But he was Isabella’s father. Cassandra was visiting her former fiance’s niece.

    Does that help? I’ve added a clarification to the post.
    Blessings to you!


  3. It is always a pleasure to interact with readers and writers who understand the depth of Jane Austen’s faith. I’m convinced also of Charlotte Bronte’s deep faith. Often, this is passed over in contemporary ‘makeovers’ of their works. I feel this causes us to miss the richness of the writing and of the time. Thanks for the book recommendation, as well!


  4. Amy, thanks for your encouragement. I’m trying to finish revising my book on Christianity in Jane Austen’s England, and figure out a direction to go on publishing it. It’s great to hear from people who are interested!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s