Christian Jane Austen Variations 3: Pamela Aidan

“I cannot deny that duty has been more often my motivation than anything approaching real devotion. . . . At least, that would be Reverend Whitefield’s assessment.” –Darcy, An Assembly Such as This, p. 24.

Book Review: “Fitzwilliam Darcy, Gentleman” series by Pamela Aidan

An Assembly Such as This, Duty and Desire, and These Three Remain


An Assembly Such as This

This compelling series was hard to put down.  At first I thought it would just be a retelling of Pride and Prejudice from Darcy’s point of view—which it is—but it is much more.  We see Darcy’s adventures during the long periods when he disappears from view in the original novel. How did he try to overcome his initial attraction to Elizabeth?  No doubt he would have searched for an appropriate woman from his own social class. In these books, he goes through exciting adventures in looking, including standing stones (like Stonehenge), ritual sacrifice, and Irish plots!  And how did he change after his first failed proposal? And how could he bring himself to search for and pay off Wickham? Christian themes are subtle in these novels. Darcy and Elizabeth are both serious about their faith and worship appropriately in Anglican churches, as Austen herself did. (In the first book Aidan mentions their singing hymns, but in the later books corrects that to singing Psalms, which was far more likely at that time.)  Darcy clearly lives a more godly life than most of his class, as the original novel implies. He also reads sermons by the famous evangelist George Whitefield. Caroline Bingley and other less-serious characters only put on a show of going to church. 110097

Duty and Desire

The second book, Duty and Desire, has the most openly religious references. It begins with a church service which includes a powerful Scripture passage confronting many of the sins prevalent in Austen’s world. However, the passage is counteracted by a sermon that waters down man’s sinfulness–typical of sermons of that time. Later in the book, Georgiana finds healing and forgiveness in a more Evangelical faith. She reads William Wilberforce’s book which confronted society’s lack of faith.  Georgiana’s new companion, Mrs. Annesley, is the widow of a clergyman very involved in helping the poor. She reminds Darcy of God’s providence and work, which has changed Georgiana’s life.  Georgiana even gets Darcy out to visit the poor of the parish, and supports a charity for “Returning Young Women to Their Friends in the Country”—young women seduced by a man’s promises, as Wickham seduced Lydia. Georgiana’s Evangelical faith is not elaborated as much as I would have liked, but it’s there. Later Darcy struggles to forgive Wickham, rather than seeking vengeance. 108759

These Three Remain

The title of the third book, These Three Remain, refers to I Corinthians 13:13: “And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love.” Aidan, in the Q&A section at the end of book 3, says, “Throughout the trilogy, these three concepts—along with the related one of mercy—have challenged duty and desire as the keys to character and living a worthy life.” Darcy, as we all know, is humbled by Elizabeth’s refusal and learns to truly love, as well as to hope. Early in this third novel, Mr. Collins preaches a sermon on “religious affection,” inspired by Lady Catherine de Bourgh. He preaches strongly against “enthusiasm.” The word “enthusiasm” described any who believed religion was a matter of the heart as well as the head, including Methodists and Evangelicals. Collins, like most non-Evangelical clergy of the time, encourages trust in “Reason, the Divine’s handmaiden,” and “self-reformation,” which Darcy realizes that he needs. The novels also refer to political and social issues, including the Luddite rebellions against industrialization, Lord Byron’s scandals, war with France, and Irish plots for independence. Quotations from Shakespeare and from Milton’s Paradise Lost are interwoven through the story. However the main emphasis is on Darcy’s internal struggles and growth. He learns to recognize the evils in his own heart, and moves toward gratitude and humility. This series is beautifully written, with fun subplots and deep insights into Darcy and Georgiana’s characters, as well as several other well-developed original characters.  A worthwhile and entertaining read. Mrs. Annesley comforts Georgiana with the truths that all things work together for good for those who love God, and that adversity brings good results in our lives in the long run (Duty and Desire, p. 45). Do these truths comfort you in your struggles today? 

More Reviews of Austen Variations

Christian Jane Austen Variations 1: Maria Grace, Robin Helm

Christian Jane Austen Variations 2: Jeanna Ellsworth, Kelsey Bryant, Janine Mendenhall

Christian Jane Austen Variations 4: Laura Hile

Christian Jane Austen Variations 5: Robin Helm and A Very Austen Valentine

Christian Jane Austen Variations 6: Barbara Cornthwaite and Lara S. Ormiston

Christian Jane Austen Variations 7: Happy Endings for Charlotte Lucas by Laura Hile and Amanda Kai

Christian Jane Austen Variations 8: Laraba Kendig and Skylar Burris

Soniah Kamal’s UnmarriageablePride and Prejudice in Pakistan

Austen Variations with Science 1: Collins Hemingway, Robin Helm, Georgette Heyer

Austen Variations with Science 2: Abigail Reynolds

Science Variations 3: Novels with Regency and Victorian Science (Linda Banche, Cindy Anstey, Elizabeth Gaskell’s North and South, Nicole Clarkston)


8 thoughts on “Christian Jane Austen Variations 3: Pamela Aidan

  1. This series looks wonderful; I’m adding these three volumes to my TBR list. 🙂

    My two favorite Christian JAFF books/series you have already reviewed in this series: Maria Grace’s Given Good Principles series (which I read as one book minus Twelfth Night at Longbourn on long ago), and Jenna Elsworth’s To Refine like Silver, my favorite Christian JAFF.

    Thank you for recommending other Christian JAFF–I can’t wait to read them all!!!

    Soli Deo Gloria,
    Susanne 🙂


  2. Thank you for including me in your reviews of JFF with Christian influences. Although my aim was to be subtle, I typically got more criticism than kudos for doing so from the general public. Either critics were incensed that they had to read something “religious” in a book they otherwise admired, or they lacked an accurate historical knowledge of the time and accused me of importing current day American evangelicalism into the British Recency era for my own nefarious reasons. Little did they know that all of my least “subtle” sermonizing came almost word for word from William Wiberforce’s fabulously popular book “A Practical View of the Prevailing Religious System of Professed Christians, in the Middle and Higher Classes in this Country, Contrasted with Real Christianity” published in 1797. I can not believe that Austen’s family did not own a copy.
    Thanks again for your gracious review.
    Pamela Aidan


    1. My pleasure, Pamela. One reason I started researching the church in Austen’s England is that I did NOT want to import modern evangelical terminology and assumptions into a novel on the time period. But I discovered that so many evangelical ideas came straight out of this time period! And I did catch you quoting Wilberforce’s wonderful book; that was a delight! The Knight family doesn’t list a copy of the book. But it was extremely widely read, and it seems very likely to me that Austen, who certainly was familiar with Hannah More, would not have read Wilberforce also; perhaps from her lending library, if her father didn’t own it. So your use of the book is very appropriate, I agree!


  3. This series is my favourite Austen Variation so far – and I think I have to re-read it during the Christmas holidays…
    But I’m also about to check out what else there is – thank you so much for all your excellent reviews!
    Greetings from Germany,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s